Rookies Heart Of Woman are gearing up for their first comeback early next month, but have dropped a surprise pre-release today. Their first album was a stuffed project that spawned several promoted tracks, though it came across as quite scattershot sonically. I’d love to hear them develop a strong, signature sound going forward, but a track like Melt is not the song to do that.
It feels like an A2O-shaped meteor has landed in K-pop this month, shifting musical trends away from the soft, shuffling pop that has dominated the industry for years now. The way K-pop works, we’ll likely need to wait a few months to see if these trends truly become inescapable, which in the meantime leaves us with a bunch of “new” music that now exists in an expired paradigm. This presents a problem for a song like Melt. A year or two ago, its subdued, amorphous sound would fit right in with many of Heart Of Woman’s peers. Today, it already sounds outdated and generic.
The song itself doesn’t do much to fight for its place, unveiling a very forgettable series of melodies over an extremely short runtime. The song wafts here and there without much intention, sprinkling a familiar, dreamlike mood that can already be acquired in pretty much any corner of K-pop’s girl group universe. It’s a whisper of a song and fails to build hype for what I hope is a more ambitious title track next month.
| Hooks | 7 |
| Production | 7 |
| Longevity | 7 |
| Bias | 7 |
| RATING | 7 |
Grade: C-
I wonder what makes the producer in Korea think these type of music is still viable to differentiate them? There’s tons and tons and plenty of similar songs in the market already. Try to make them different!
Anyway your thoughts on TWS’s teasers? I would say I’m giving hope on it, they’re just not yet disappointing me.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Initially, I was afraid the title track sounded too soft for what I want, but I’m slowly coming around to the idea and I like the symphonic hints we’ve been getting in the instrumental so far. We’ll see on Monday, I guess!
LikeLiked by 2 people
H.O.W’s 13 track debut suffers from the thrown at the wall genre shifts kpop is all about but ultimately there was a common throughline of strong vocals, robust beats and confidence. This brand of wimpy fluff fits many girl groups for better and worse but H.O.W was not one of them. You have to hope their title is better but I’m not sure if they thought this ill fitting trend chasing gasp of air was the best first impression for it.
LikeLike
i had a stroke reading this
LikeLike
This song is a bit bland and unmemorable. It feels like a flatline throughout the entire runtime. Maybe a flat 7 like you.
The A2O bomb has landed quite well, with Neon doing very well on Korean charts, probably the best performing song all year on those charts. It is also doing well on global charts too. Maybe A2O Lite’s Neon was Nick’s true birthday wish* close to the anniversary NMIXX’s Blue Valentine instead of whatever NMIXX released a week later.
*I know that Infinite’s The Chaser got released on your birthday. I am a bit jealous that nothing close to that quality released on my birthday.
LikeLike
The best kpop birthday I ever had was f(x)’s 4 Walls album coming out on my birthday in 2015. Sad in retrospect that it was also the last album I’d get from them, but at the time it was like a gift bestowed by the universe.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The point of Kpop is to sound unique and differentiate itself from the western world while taking inspiration from it sometimes. This is blatantly just a PinkPantheress rip off, it’s useless and not even a good copycat.
LikeLike