As K-pop pushes past the finish line of its (very long) Y2K trend, we’ve somehow made it to the end without artists pulling from the bolder, more garish sounds of that era. This has resulted in a tasteful, subdued and vibes-based version of Y2K, squandering what could have been a very interesting modernization of nostalgic influences. For Nayeon’s newest single, she’s borrowed the garishness of stereotypical Y2K imagery, but the music remains frustratingly grounded.
Nayeon’s solo singles have been spectacular so far — particularly 2024’s ABCD. And, I mean this in the literal sense of the word: “spectacular,” as in “spectacle.” I wouldn’t necessarily call Baby Angel “subdued,” but it is frustratingly familiar. Its production sounds like a hodgepodge of so many other songs we’ve heard over the past few years, vaguely R&B but mostly a string of samples fashioned into a functional groove. The track has rhythm, but never really grabs hold of the funk to become a siren call that forces your body to move.
Instead, Baby Angel relies on many quick, repeated hooks delivered in a sing-song cadence. Occasionally, the song is punctured by a jarring succession of ascending notes, but this comes across as more frantic than thrilling. At just over two minutes, the whole thing is over before you know it, stuffing many moments into its narrow frame without ever paying off in a meaningful way. After the absolute showstoppers Nayeon’s delivered in the past, this restless, unresolved energy feels like a missed opportunity.
| Hooks | 7 |
| Production | 8 |
| Longevity | 8 |
| Bias | 7 |
| RATING | 7.5 |
Grade: C
1. Baby Angel
Analysis: This feels very much tailored for TikTok, and it is terribly short! This is definitely a step down from releases like “ABCD” and even “POP!” I can easily imagine a random TikTok creator putting this out, only for it to vanish into thin air after a couple of weeks. The chorus is most certainly structured around short-form video trends, and the beat doesn’t offer much dynamic movement. Furthermore, the odd bridge breakdown felt rather out of place and jarring.
8.25 (8, 8, 8, 9)
2. SHiVER
Analysis: Now, this track carries a sonic aesthetic reminiscent of NewJeans. The shimmery synths remind me a little bit of Lovelyz’s signature styling, though the heavy trap elements and repetitive sing-talk style become a bit tiring to listen to.
8
3. Boy
Analysis: This one is nice and funky! The sound effects shimmering in the background carry a wonderful sense of etherealness, reminiscent of S.E.S.’s classic “Dreams Come True.” Interestingly enough, this is also the longest track on the mini-album (hmm, I certainly wonder why that correlation exists!).
8.5 ( 8, 9, 8, 9)
Final Thoughts
Overall, this release isn’t bad by any means, but it feels more like a sideways step rather than a step up for her artistry.
Overall Rating: 8.25
LikeLike
im serious, how did we not get a single cheiron-esque song throughout the y2k trend, ur telling me not a single company even thought to make a song like nsync???
LikeLike