It’s hard to overstate just how important representation is in media, especially when it comes to minority groups. And with South Korea among the more socially conservative Asian countries, members of the LGBT community rarely see themselves within its idol and actor driven entertainment industry. When representation is present, it’s usually treated as something of a gag. Compare this to the rampant same-sex fetishization (ie: “shipping”) of k-pop idols among a large subset of fans, and you’ve got a really interesting dichotomy. On the surface, the k-pop industry feels rife with subversions of traditional gender norms, stylizing its male idols with full make-up and cute, aegyo appeals that would certainly raise a few eyebrows in the West. But this all seems to begin and end on the stage.
Enter, Holland: the first openly gay idol to promote in South Korea. And he arrives not with some glitzy performance piece, but with the understated Neverland (네버랜드). This is a huge moment for the industry, soundtracked by a song that couldn’t be more subdued. And in a way, this juxtaposition is kind of brilliant. Neverland feels like the aural equivalent to an indie, art house film. It unfolds in a slow — almost dreamlike — haze, driven by a deep strings riff that creeps forward with gorgeous resonance. The song’s production is its biggest strength, supporting Neverland‘s slight melody with a lavish soundscape that works as a terrific foil to Holland’s unique vocals.
Ultimately, Neverland is too muted to make much of an impression as a song — especially at first. But further listens pull out more of its laid-back charms, and Holland’s comfortable delivery soon becomes surprisingly addictive. It may not be the kind of throw-down-the-gauntlet debut we’d expect from a rookie, but the song (and video) will likely remain k-pop’s most important moment of 2018.
Yeah I don’t care much for the song whatsoever, but as a member of the LGBT community this is huge for me. I’m glad he made the brave choice to debut as an idol in SK while still speaking his truth.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve been seeing more people than I expected expressing things like “the song isn’t for me, but I love the MV and support what he’s doing” and honestly I think a lot more people would be on board with the song if it weren’t for his vocals….while his voice is definitely distinctive, it’s also unpolished enough to border on grating for me despite the fact that I really like the song itself (esp. the production, like you said).
To be fair, though, he only just debuted and there’s plenty of room for him to improve, which I hope he does. It would be really satisfying to see him push himself and prove wrong the naysayers who are accusing him of just using his orientation as a way to grab attention.
But like you also mentioned—even if he doesn’t, what he did here is really important in and of itself and he deserves credit for it.
It doesn’t have much to do with his vocals for me. In fact, because his voice a bit rough around the edges instead of being hyper-polished like 99% of kpop songs, it becomes the most interesting thing about the song. This sort of smooth piano and strings venture isn’t something I ever like. That voice could make a cool song, but nothing ever really happens musically in this one.
Pingback: Song Review: Holland – I’m Not Afraid | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: The Top 10 K-Pop Rookies of 2018 | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: The Top 10 K-Pop Music Videos of 2018 | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: Song Review: Holland – Number Boy – The Music Weekly