After kicking off the year with the colorful music video for power ballad Paint Me, Mamamoo have embarked on a release schedule centered around colors and seasons. March gave us Yellow Flower and the folksy EDM of Starry Night, and now the girls have moved onto “red” summer with the Latin-pop of Egotistic (너나 해).
Upon first listen, it’s clear that there’s more meat on Egotistic’s bones than the instrumental-focused Starry Night. The song has a dynamic structure, drawing a strong balance between its impressive production and Mamamoo’s enviable vocals. Opening with a brief flourish of Latin guitar, the first verse gradually builds as more percussive elements are added to the mix. This culminates in the chorus’s resounding stomp, which blends the girls’ voices for a chant-like hook that is hard to resist.
As much as the Latin trend seems to be taking hold in K-pop, I’m not sure that it’s a perfect match for Mamamoo. The girls can carry just about any genre, but Egotistic’s beat-driven structure doesn’t allow them much opportunity to unleash the kind of harmony and power notes that made their earlier work so idiosyncratic. Beyond the standout chorus, too much of the track feels like set-up. This set-up is beautiful and sultry, but I’d prefer more engaging verses that better matched the energy of Egotistic‘s hook. 2016’s Decalcomanie felt like a masterclass on how to achieve this sense of structural tension, but I’m concerned that Mamamoo’s music is starting to favor trendiness over careful song construction.
Mamamoo is one of my favorite groups – the songwriting, production, singing and performances are always top notch – but their style has always gone slightly against the grain of mainstream K-pop, which is the primary reason I love them. I’m willing to cut them some slack with this song – it’s not bad, but it is somewhat less sophisticated than their previous singles. I’m looking forward to hearing the new album!
The album is more varied than anything else they’ve released, for sure.
Pingback: Top Three K-Pop Songs of July 2018 | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: Song Review: Mamamoo – Wind Flower | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
In my own personal preference, Red Moon is the best album. Decalcomanie was the song that brings me to Mamamoo. It sounds so idiosyncratic. I agree that Egotistic doesn’t have such complex structure compare to Decalcomanie, but Egotistic has some kind of mysterious energy that Decalcomanie doesn’t. Why don’t you write a review for Rainy Season. It’s a very good song too.
Pingback: Song Review – Mamamoo – gogobebe | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: Song Review: BVNDIT – Dumb | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion