Song Review: Bae Jinyoung – Hard To Say Goodbye

Another day, another post-Wanna One debut. And like so many of these solo tracks, Bae Jinyoung’s Hard to Say Goodbye (끝을 받아들이기가 어려워) is a ballad. This fact alone makes it difficult to drum up any interest, as you essentially know what you’re going to get before the song even starts. Jinyoung never felt like a huge vocal presence in Wanna One, especially when competing with bigger voices in the group. So at the very least, I guess it’s nice to hear his tone a little more clearly in this unadorned tearjerker.

Though he might not be the bombastic belter that usually performs these kind of songs, I actually quite like the sound of Jinyoung’s voice. It’s slightly deeper and huskier than many of his counterparts, at times recalling V from BTS. What he lacks in oomph, he makes up for with sentimentality — a vital component to these kind of swelling ballads.

Unfortunately, when it comes down to it Hard to Say Goodbye is still a by-the-numbers pop ballad. It never really builds to anything memorable, even if it does a good job conveying its gloomy mood. The production is delicate throughout, driven by an all-too-familiar mix of piano and strings. If it ain’t broke, why fix it? The problem is, all of these tracks end up blending together. So far, no agency has shown an ounce of creativity when it comes to their returning Wanna One artists. We’ll see what happens when Jinyoung debuts with his upcoming group, but for now there’s not a lot to feel excited about.

 Hooks 7
 Production 7
 Longevity 7
 Bias 7



2 thoughts on “Song Review: Bae Jinyoung – Hard To Say Goodbye

  1. Never underestimate Korea’s love of cheesy ballads. They make up fully half of the Gaon charts, and 3/4s of the karaoke charts. How they distinguish this ballad from that ballad as the one for the month, I have no idea, unless it is like Park Hyo Shin or something.

    His singing is not bad. He sounds a bit like a baby Yesung. He has a good developing falsetto. In a real typical boy kpop group – not one based upon visuals and voting and all that, he could have been a typical male lead vocal or second vocal.

    Hey, you missed the key change. I mean, most K ballads build build build …. and then return to exactly the same key. And then last for another minute of full verse and chorus. (qv just about any solo ballad from my hyunnie Kyu, whose bridge lands at about 330 or 400 and then keeps going for another full minute or more).
    This one: bridge, one line, key change, repeat chorus, and end vocal, then a little piano tinkly coda. Which structurally makes it more western-style. Otherwise, yeah, this one blends in.


  2. Pingback: Ranking K-pop’s Post-Wanna One Debuts | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.