With K-pop becoming more global by the year, it makes sense that we’re seeing more acts specifically target Western audiences. BTS have gone about this the right way, refusing to sacrifice their sound (or language) simply to fit in. Too many K-pop artist have tried to crack the American market with sub-par, English-language material. Few of these efforts have resulted in decent songs, and that’s no surprise. Who wants to hear an artist performing in a language that’s not their own, with a sound that’s bending backwards to conform to another culture’s preferences?
With this in mind, Monsta X’s first English-language single is not half bad. I would have preferred a mostly-Korean performance, as it would have felt more authentic, but other than the lyrics, Who Do U Love feels as if it could have been plucked straight from the K-pop charts. The song draws influence from New Edition-inspired retro r&b, augmented by today’s trendy, Charlie Puth-esque beat drops. It’s a nice blend, anchored by a catchy hook that feels very classic boy band. And unlike most English-language tracks by K-pop artists, the lyrics won’t make your toes curl. Monsta X were smart to stick to vague platitudes like “who’s the one who takes you higher than you’ve ever been?” over swaggy posturing.
Speaking of swaggy posturing, I could do without the French Montana feature. He bursts in during verse two to remind us why U.S. pop music is in such a sorry state. His “skrrt, skrrt,” autotuned performance puts an automatic expiration date on the track, at odds with the refined vibe all around it. Thankfully, his segment is relatively brief, and it actually has an unexpected side effect. Taking all the hip-hop spotlight for himself, Montana has forced rappers Jooheon and I.M into vocal positions. This is especially revelatory when it comes to Jooheon, who delivers some pitch-perfect, Michael Jackson ad-libs that give the track unexpected funk. I’d love to hear more of this in Monsta X’s Korean work.
Btw, I.M and Kihyun are only in the chorus (I.m’s voice can’t really be heard, but kihyun is leading with shownu)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hope I.M. will take French Montana’s part during the live perfs, maybe with a verse of his own. Great song overall
LikeLiked by 1 person
That would vastly improve the track (and give I.M. something to do!)
I thought it was basic boy band, half Korean half American style, half 2010’s half 1990’s, not half bad and not half good, and all just kinda not my style.
Pingback: Song Review: Monsta X – Middle Of The Night | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
Pingback: Song Review: Monsta X – If With U | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion
its been what? 2-3 years now, and I’m still salty at how they were f’ed over by French Montana
I love everything else in the song but that terrible rap is really giving me the ick
also, he flat out ruined their live performances and I’m still mad
my boys did great though ♡♡ I still listen to that album
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH but french montana honestly ruined it.. i did not like his rap. it was genuinely so bad💀 sorry had to say it🤷🤷 MX ARE LITERALLY SUCH GOOD SINGERS THO FRFR?? MONSTA X>>>