Feature

Battle of the B-Sides: SHINee, Miss A, Girls’ Generation, BTOB, SF9

Battle of the B-sidesK-pop’s title tracks might gain most of listeners’ attention, but many album tracks are worth equal spotlight. I call these “buried treasures.”

Beyond this, K-pop’s albums deliver thousands of additional tracks that settle for a more limited audience. It’s these songs that will become a part of my “battle of the b-sides” feature.

In this feature, I’ll be putting on my A&R hat and taking a listen to five randomly-selected K-pop b-sides. I’ll write a mini review for each, including a Bias List rating, and rank them from least to most favorite. The winner will join a special Bias List B-side playlist. Think of it like my own little agency, hand-selecting songs I’d like to pitch to my nonexistent artists!

You can check out all rounds of my Battle of the B-sides here!


Battle of the B-sides: Round Thirty-Two


SHINee – All Day All Night (2018)


Dropping SHINee into a “battle of the b-sides” mix is almost unfair. They’re basically kings of b-sides, and their entire Story Of Light album would be very competitive in any match-up. With that said, I remember being underwhelmed the first time I heard this track. You all know how it bugs me when choruses lurch into half-time, and All Day All Night’s perky verses seem to promise a centerpiece that’s equally energetic. However, SHINee’s incredible vocal blend more than compensates for my issues with the instrumental. Their voices form a towering sucker punch, driving the track with both power and emotion.

 Hooks 8
 Production 8
 Longevity 9
 Bias 9
 RATING 8.5

Miss A – Time’s Up (2012)


Answering SHINee’s challenge, Miss A is up next with a strong b-side. Ooh, this is gonna be a good match-up! Time’s Up conforms to many of the production tropes of its era – namely, that LMFAO-style electro wiggle that was a particular favorite of Brave Brothers’ productions. This is not a Brave Brothers production, but follows the template to great success. I love the bounciness of the instrumental, especially when the girls’ vocals join the percussion in a rhythmic structure. The verses aren’t all that memorable, but the air clears for a standout pre-chorus and super fun drop.

 Hooks 8
 Production 9
 Longevity 8
 Bias 9
 RATING 8.5

Girls’ Generation – I’m In Love With The Hero (2011)


Yep, this is going to be a strong week. There’s no messing around with Girls’ Generation’s J-pop b-sides, and I’m In Love With The Hero is no different. The electro pulse that fuels this track is nothing short of beguiling. The drumline percussion makes an unexpected bedfellow, but the song is all the stronger for it. The chorus has great surge. It’s a simple melody, but arranged to feel intense and cathartic. And as usual, the girls sell every moment with addictive confidence. The track even makes room for some experimental turns, ensuring a sense of spontaneity.

 Hooks 8
 Production 9
 Longevity 9
 Bias 9
 RATING 8.75

BTOB – Broken Heart (끝난 건가요) (2014)


It’s about time my randomizer selected a ballad, though BTOB’s Broken Heart has a satisfying 90’s groove that makes it more of a slow-burn than an OST belter. This sound is the group’s bread and butter, and they can always be counted on to deliver the goods. Their discography holds stronger examples of this style, but I still think this is a solid track. It’s always a pleasure to hear the guys cut loose and bring the vocal firepower. The arrangement here is very satisfying, allowing BTOB to imbue intensity into every moment. I only long for a more memorable melody.

 Hooks 8
 Production 8
 Longevity 8
 Bias 8
 RATING 8

SF9 – Hide And Seek (2017)


There are an alarming number of great K-pop songs with the title “Hide and Seek,” and I think we can safely add SF9’s effort to the list. Their current work is often sleek and serious, but this takes us back to a more effusive pop sound. Hide And Seek has a nice brassy swing, augmenting the typical “bright” boy group style with a live band feel that injects plenty of energy. The guys were pretty early into their career when this was recorded, and it fits their youthful charm well. Hide And Seek also allows for some fun vocal riffs that bring an improvisational spark to an otherwise straightforward effort.

 Hooks 8
 Production 9
 Longevity 8
 Bias 8
 RATING 8.25

My Verdict:


Fifth: BTOB – Broken Heart
Fourth: SF9 – Hide And Seek
Third: miss A – Time’s Up
Second: SHINee – All Day All Night

First: Girls’ Generation – I’m In Love With The Hero


Congratulations to Girls’ Generation’s I’m In Love With The Hero – the thirty-second winner of my Battle of the B-sides!

Readers, what do you think? Did you discover any hidden gems? Leave your own ranking in the comments!

8 thoughts on “Battle of the B-Sides: SHINee, Miss A, Girls’ Generation, BTOB, SF9

  1. I’m not a huge Miss A fan, and I’d never heard this b-side before, but I loved it! It might be because I’m rather fond of Brave Brothers-style production, but I think that song would be my winner for this match-up.

    Like

  2. I’m a Huge fan of SHINee and Girls Generation, So my love goes towards them A Lot.
    Their are Very Few song’s of SHINee that I Dislike. Most Korean & Japanese Song’s, were written by Jonghyun, but even before his passing, Key & Minho we’re writing their Own Rap parts. Now All of them, Accept Minho, has an Solo album out.

    Like

  3. This was a very strong round, I liked every song on here. SNSD’s “I’m in love with the hero” is my top pick which is most likely due to how long I’ve known it for.

    Like

  4. What other “Hide & Seek” songs are you referring to? CLC? LOONA? Lovelyz? Astro?

    Also, I find it interesting how many kpop songs have really distinct titles like “Swamp of Despair” and how there are just as many that use the same title “tonight”, “I love you”, “starry night”, I can go on forever lol

    Liked by 1 person

  5. hide and seek is going to be a new favorite of mine– it puts me in such a good mood!! i’m also happy to listen to a song from the story of light other than who waits for love because i always get distracted listening to that one and forget to listen to the rest of the album!

    now off to put hide and seek in all my sunny day playlists!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.