Song Review: Xiumin (EXO) – You

When all is said and done, it’s starting to feel like 2019 will be known as the year of debuts and military enlistments. The number of high-profile enlistments that have occurred over the past few months has been staggering, as K-pop’s much-loved second generation of male groups take various forms of hiatus. There’s a new generation of acts waiting in the wings, poised to bring a different energy to the industry. I’m excited to see how it all turns out.

With most enlistments comes a last hurrah gift for the fans. In SM Entertainment’s case, this is almost always in the form of some sappy ballad, and the formula is starting to wear thin. It doesn’t help that the agency has spent most of 2019 clogging their discography with like-minded tracks, causing each to run into another. It’s hard to review songs like Xiumin’s You (이유). Objectively, none of them are all that interesting. I don’t think they’re designed to be. But, they’re milestones unto themselves, celebrating a seminal moment in any performer’s career.

With Xiumin’s enlistment, his group EXO enters a state of flux. They’re one of K-pop’s biggest acts, and their changing presence will likely send shock waves throughout the industry. This makes You quite bittersweet, and also makes me yearn for a much more interesting take on the “farewell single.” Placed aside bigger vocalists, Xiumin has never received much solo spotlight. Because of this, it’s nice to hear him take the reins completely. He does an admirable job within You’s sentimental trappings, but the song feels like a rewrite of a rewrite. If you’ve heard any OST-sounding ballad of the past decade, you’ll know what to expect. A performer as energetic as Xiumin probably deserved more, but it’s hard to completely rain on his very earned parade.

 Hooks 7
 Production 7
 Longevity 7
 Bias 6
 RATING 6.75



5 thoughts on “Song Review: Xiumin (EXO) – You

  1. I am convinced hat somewhere there is an OST ballad generator buried in a basement in Seoul that cranks these kind of songs out. This is a genre that only exists in Korea. Like a guy, behind an old desk “How many strings you want, low medium, high. Highest note? OK, B flat, we can do B flat. Song about (check one) finding love, being in love, missing love, losing love, never having love; set in spring summer fall winter; school uniform yes/no … and etc..

    It is pleasant and perfectly average OST-type ballad. Xiumin is a pleasant and perfectly competent singer. That is all.


    • An OST ballad generator lmao

      But yes you are right. Xiumin deserved a song more seriously composed and well thought out than this. But considering how SM entertainment doesnt really seem interested in spending resources and giving their all to anyone but certain artists here and there, its not surprising. The song makes me sad so it does its work, I guess.


  2. Talking about ballads, nick , you should review “MAY BY YOU” by Onestar ft Chen that released today. Its a good one ,I promise, and the high notes give me chills.


  3. Pingback: Song Review: D.O. (EXO) – That’s Okay | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion

  4. Pingback: Song Review: Xiumin (EXO) – Brand New | The Bias List // K-Pop Reviews & Discussion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.