Feature

Six K-Pop Idol Variety Concepts I’d Like to See (Instead of another survival series)

On top of everything else, I’m a voracious consumer of idol variety shows. I love nothing more than a great idol variety concept. As K-pop has grown more popular internationally, most idol variety has moved online. Usually the “episodes” are bite-sized – designed with this meme-happy generation in mind.

The longer, TV-based series that still exist are mostly competition or survival-themed, like Produce 101 and Road to Kingdom. Gone is the day of robust idol variety on Korea’s bigger networks. Even most of the online content boils down to tried-and-true ideas like behind-the-scenes material, interviews and eating broadcasts (which I’ve never seen the appeal of).

So, I’ve decided to publish an “if I ruled the K-pop industry” decree.

TV producers, you can thank me now for the hours of brainstorming I’ve saved you. It’s time for an idol variety renaissance! Here are five new treatments (plus, one old favorite) that could reinvigorate the genre. Unsurprisingly, most highlight collaboration and bonding over competition and elimination.


“Maknaes on Top”

The pitch: What would happen if the maknaes of several idol acts had to become leaders of their own ragtag groups?

The details: There are a few old variety series that focus on K-pop maknaes (youngest members), but this would be different. A small group of maknaes from different idol groups would meet and have some sort of brief competition. Then, it would be revealed that each maknae would be in charge of training their own idol group, consisting entirely of K-pop fans and amateur performers.

Based on the results of the initial game/competition, the maknaes would take turns assembling their own group from a pre-selected roster of participants. Then, each week they’d need to train them in a cover dance, competing as part of the group in the role of leader. I suppose there could be eliminations until the winning group is announced, or it could simple be points-based, and the highest points at the end of the series wins. Either way, putting these idols into a leadership role would be really fun and rewarding to watch. Plus, the fan interaction would be great.


“So Much Better” (K-Pop Edition)

The pitch: A handful of artists from different genres and generations hang out in a remote summer house and reinterpret each other’s songs.

The details: Okay, I totally stole this format from a hit Swedish show I used to watch called Så mycket bättre (So Much Better). But, I think it’s one of the most enjoyable music TV concepts I’ve ever seen. The premise is simple. Seven or eight artists (or idol groups) gather together in a remote summer house, where they live for a week or so. Each day is its own episode, and is devoted to one of the artists. During that day, the spotlight artist picks an activity for the group to do (game, outing, craft… whatever represents their interests) and also selects the meals for the day.

At night, they all gather around a big dining table that’s placed in front of an intimate stage. One by one, the other artists take turns performing a favorite track from the spotlighted artist’s discography, usually rearranging it to fit their own style. In between, the spotlighted artist shares stories behind the songs and memories of their career. These reinterpreted songs are then released digitally. It may sound simple, but more often than not the show packed an emotional wallop, and was an excellent showcase for skill and bonding without the need for a competitive aspect. In Sweden, it reignited many musical careers. I think it could do the same in Korea.


“Backwards, and in High Heels”

The pitch: A girl group coaches a boy group to perform one of their songs, and vice versa.

The details: Each episode could be split into two parts, or even two episodes. One girl group and one boy group would join forces to cover each other’s songs. One week, the girl group would coach the boy group, and the next week they could flip the roles. Each episode would culminate in the performance, maybe at a fan meet or some other public showcase.

The trick is, this couldn’t just be an exercise in cross-dressing, which would obviously come off as insensitive and backwards. In fact, it shouldn’t be played for laughs at all. Instead, it would be fun to see the groups really try to understand what it takes to perform each other’s songs, down to the smallest details. When it came time to unveil the final product, the groups wouldn’t be trying to copy the look or sound of each other, but instead find a way to showcase the track’s energy and concept in their own way.


“K-Pop Meets J-Pop”

The pitch: K-Pop and J-Pop idol stars meet for friendly competition and the chance to reinterpret each other’s songs.

The details: Okay, I’ve longed for this particular concept for years, and I doubt it’ll ever happen. But, in my wildest dreams, a series exists that brings together Korean and Japanese idol groups for a field day of sorts. Obviously, there would be a language barrier. But, it would be fascinating to see the contrast, and maybe even have an opportunity for the artists to discuss the differences and similarities in their respective industries.

I imagine that this show would be lighthearted and fun, with a few of the classic, silly variety show games. There could be a competitive element, but it wouldn’t need to be taken very seriously. The two teams could share a meal together, and maybe even close out the show by performing each other’s songs.


“Undercover Idol”

The pitch: Idols learn the day-to-day drudgery of “normal” jobs by going undercover as new employees in various fields.

The details: This is another concept I pretty much stole… this time from Undercover Boss. Basically, each week an idol would get some sort of disguise or make-up so that they could pose as a new employee in whatever occupation was being spotlighted. We’d watch them get trained and learn the ropes, and eventually they’d reveal their true identity. Or, the show could forgo the theatrics entirely and just have them show up as they are with the aim to gain experience in a new field. If done correctly, it could be an enjoyable slice-of-life series that’s both funny and heartwarming.


“Let’s Go! Dream Team”

I don’t have anything to say about this show except that I used to love watching it, and I wish they’d bring it back. It was such a great spotlight for underrated idol groups, and managed to be competitive while still being fun and lighthearted.

Relive the glory by watching KBS’s youtube playlist:


What do you think, readers? Would you watch any of these series? Do you have some ideas of your own?

15 thoughts on “Six K-Pop Idol Variety Concepts I’d Like to See (Instead of another survival series)

  1. I am fairly confident that Super Junior have done all or a variation of most of these. Of course though they have had 15 years to do it in. Heck, I think they have done it both collectively, and separately as individuals.

    (And yes, backwards in high heels many times. SuJu is famous for drag at the Super Show concerts. Sometimes they drag Max Changmin into it too. Max not so secretly wishes he was in SuJu.)

    Not that this isn’t a good list of ideas. It is a very good list of ideas.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’d love to see Undercover Idol actually happen, though I can already anticipate the secondhand embarrassment.

    There was a popular tweet a while ago about a hypothetical show where idol groups swap leaders for a certain period of time that I would absolutely die to see. Especially for larger/smaller and female/male ones; it’d be such a cool look at group dynamics.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The k-pop meets j-pop one seems really interesting and I would like to see it… if there weren’t barriers other than language

    Like

  4. Amazing. Now get this translated and published on Pann.

    Myself, I’d give (the tip of) a (pinky) finger for the “Maknaes on Top” concept, although Koreans will probably make it so that trainees are the ones to act as members of the ragtag group and the maknae in question ends up as some sort of Produce coach. But still I’d be great, even with non-maknaes. I imagine Monsta X Minhyuk or Jangjun as group leaders. Perhaps Johnny from NCT.

    Oh, and the Swedish format show sounds great too. A great way for a relative noob like me to meet the great oldies I don’t know where to start with. I’m sure it’d be popular if they mix them with a few of the popular youngsters.

    Like

  5. I’m down with all of these ideas. Personally, I would love to “Maknaes on top” and “dream team”. I think So much better is a great concept, but some groups don’t seem to have a distinct sound, but there are many groups who do and would make the show worthwhile.

    Like

  6. Now, as a fan of variety shows, with or without idols, i think i have saw some similar to these:

    “So Much Better”

    There’s a few that had artist living on the same space ironically, the closest things idols had for this is Queendom’s collab stages.

    “K-pop meets J-pop”

    Produce 48. It’s met with some hatred considering korea japan relationship so…..gonna be hard to do a peaceful one.

    “Undercover Idol”

    Mostly youtube series does this, it was more “prank” focused tho.

    Like

  7. And my ideas would be:

    “The Swap”

    Switch out one members from two groups, have them try living and practicing together with their new groups, and then have a comeback (If yoo jae suk could do it with exo, anybody could!)

    “Idol Escape Show”

    Have a gigantic room escapes involving a bunch of idols that never talks to each other, it would be an awkward masterpiece (Also, go watch “The Great Escape”. I want something like that more.)

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I need Star Golden Bell back!!! They’ve done a few 1 episode reboots, but Star Golden Bell was my favorite variety show back in the day. I just miss shows that brought together idols from different groups and had them play games or compete, etc. And what was great about Star Golden Bell was the first part was more like a talk show and then they played the super fun games. Such a classic.

    Like

  9. Great Idea. I particularly enjoyed the Maknae on top concept and where the idols would go undercover. Not only is it intertaining but we could also see the idol’s personality off the stage. Great post! very creative pdnim.

    Like

    • .com, unfortunately. I’d love to be able to install plugins — particularly to make some elements of commenting easier, but the thought of switching over is really intimidating and scares me (and wordpress’s paid plans are ridiculously overpriced).

      Like

  10. Oh these all sound wonderful and I long for the days where having multiple idols from different groups and companies on one show was the norm rather than something special. If I could bring a concept back, it’d probably be Invincible Youth. The first season was much better than the second, true, but I really do enjoy the concept behind it and if you select the right group of people it could be really fun. I just wanna see idols plant rice and chase after cows and chickens, not cookie cutter elimination show after cookie cutter elimination show

    Like

  11. Maknae on Top is something I’ve been wondering for a while why nobody has actually done it. Backward and in High heels would also be interesting.
    The most difficult would be the Jpop and Kpop one, although it would be great to see the two worlds link, I think the language barrier will be a huge minus point to let the program have a flow that does not bother the viewer.

    I get the feeling we have been stuck in the same kind of idol shows forever since TV has been losing to other platforms like VLIVE, and it’s a shame.

    Like

  12. The concept of a newer group to reinterpret Infinite’s discography…. sounds interesting…. But I’m quite afraid recent releases will have them reinterpreting the songs as trap/basic electronic, or worse, tropical house.

    On the other hand, I will go down for a boygroup learning girlgroup dances seriously. Especially the sexy/cute ones, not the girl crushes ones!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.