Review

Song Review: Vernon (Seventeen) – Black Eye

Vernon - Black EyeWith a group as large as Seventeen, there’s ample opportunity for solo projects. No member has released an entire album yet, but many of the guys have delivered solo singles – whether in the form of a proper comeback or a digital mixtape. Despite taking the role of rapper on Seventeen’s group tracks, Vernon’s Black Eye sees him tackling an anthemic rock sound. This is in line with many of his peers in 2022, and it makes for a surprisingly solid match.

Vernon is not a singer’s singer, but I think that’s an asset on a track like. The imperfections in his performance give Black Eye extra grit – similar to how G-Dragon’s raw vocal in Crooked made that song such a classic. Black Eye is no Crooked – not even close, really – but it evokes some of the same energy. The instrumental feels more indebted to 80’s indie rock, bounding out of the gate with propulsive percussion that even incorporates some synth.

When Black Eye indulges in a few well-placed breakdowns, they’re opportunities for the guitar to take center stage. I love this punky sound, even if it feels a bit sanitized here. Black Eye’s melodies are also solid – especially that shout-along chorus. My biggest complaint is actually the choice to bleep the expletive in this hook. In the context of the song’s intensity and lyrical content, it’s pretty lame. The move feels overly calculated, like “look at me, I’m so badass (but not really that badass please stream and play this on the radio)”. If you’re going full-on punk, commitment is key. Let the curse words fly, Vernon!

Hooks 8
 Production 9
 Longevity 8
 Bias 9
 RATING 8.5

Grade: B

11 thoughts on “Song Review: Vernon (Seventeen) – Black Eye

  1. I actually really like the melodies and instrumental but those lyrics? The verse after the first chorus had me rolling, they’re so simple and cheesy that I WISH I could call it camp but alas they look serious about those lines.

    Anyways, it’s still fun to listen to and I love punk (even though I wish a good amount of kpop songs would lean FULLY into the genres they take inspiration from (seems like such a waste too! have you seen how much fans love calling their favs different and revolutionary? a missed opportunity if you ask me)).

    Rating: 8

    Liked by 3 people

  2. I cringed so hard at the lyrics. Vernon, my sweet child, you can tell he speaks fluently (being that his mom’s American) but his English lyrical writing and slang is off by far. Nevertheless, I thoroughly enjoyed this song!!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I am always really shocked at how fast you write your reviews (this is a compliment!) – thank you for that!

    Like some other people said, I like the instrumentals and melody a lot (especially the outro of the song, call me cheesy but I love the “Knock, knock is there anybody out there?”) but most of the lyrics are just *a little* too on the nose for me. Maybe it’s because I am used to the sometimes incredibly wordy and complicated (for better or for worse) lyrics from the likes of Fall Out Boy when thinking about this genre, but I would have enjoyed a little more spontaneity. And yes. Let Vernon curse!

    That said it’s fun to listen to and you can tell Vernon really enjoyed working on it! It has me dreaming up other songs in the genre that I would love Vernon to cover one day too, which is always fun. I enjoyed it, and I’ll probably warm up to it more over time!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. He had the right idea with lyrics– bad boy-ish character being too dependent on their partner while also too emotionally unstable to uphold a relationship– but the way the theme was delivered just… wasn’t it. Lyrics aside it’s a solid song and a fun listen 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.