Review

Song Review: WHIB – Bang Out

Last year, WHIB surprised in a delightful way with the bright funk energy of Rush Of Joy, instantly putting them on my radar. For new single Bang Out, it seems they got that “joy” stuff out of their system and are now back to typical boy group posturing.

Groups like this are what I consider “K-pop’s working class.” Rather than develop their own sound and artistic vision, they flit between trends and styles depending on who their agency purchases material from. Unless every song is a 9+ rated masterpiece, this constant shift makes it very hard to feel any attachment to a group. Rush Of Joy probably could have been performed equally well by anyone, and the same can be said about Bang Out. The difference is, this song is far less enjoyable and quite irritating at times.

We open with a familiar shout-rap assault that feels like a dozen gnats buzzing around your ears. If I could somehow pull shout rap and sing talk from K-pop’s lexicon, we’d all be in a better place. Nearly all of Bang Out follows this approach. Even when the guys are singing, the lines are clipped and flattened of any notable curves. It’s not rhythmic enough to be effective rap and not anthemic enough to match the rock-meets-hip-hop instrumental. Instead, Bang Out sounds like an annoying hissy fit. Apparently, the rush of joy is over and we’ve hit the sugar crash.

Hooks 6
 Production 8
 Longevity 7
 Bias 7
 RATING 7

Grade: C-

4 thoughts on “Song Review: WHIB – Bang Out

  1. The struggle is real. Does this song even have a key?

    I say these things, but as a mom I really feel for all these kids in these working class groups. There are at least twice too many groups for the size of the market, so only a fraction actually earn a living. Then there is all the social pressures of being an idol, which is bad in any country but Korea seems to be especially good at the pile on. I hope it works out for these boys here.

    Like

  2. Bring back singing and ban shout talk/rap…its so unnecessary and unpleasant. I do like the instrumental and that’s about it. There’s too many groups and most of them are not doing anything interesting with their sound…such a shame.

    Like

  3. I don’t listen to the main groups putting out this kind of sound so I wasn’t as put off or tired of the sound. Probably would be different if I listened to more of this type.

    For now I’ll give it 7,8,7,8 = 7.5

    Like

Leave a reply to Shan Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.